Caveat: This is an extremely biased review from a star-wars fan. To elucidate my point- i even liked parts of episode 1 and 2. So there, you have been warned
Imagine that you are solving jigsaw puzzle and are a couple of pieces away from completion. You know the whole picture already or at the very least have some definite ideas about it. Sure you'll go ahead and complete the puzzle, but if the initial excitement levels can be sustained, then we have something phenomenal.
Imagine a movie in which the what-happened-before is known( Anakin Skywalker is a jedi knight who is supposed to bring balance to the Force switches to the Dark Side) , the what-happens-next is known (Luke and Leia will eventually battle the Empire (and Darth vader who is the "post Anakin" Skywalker) and restore justice among other things. Only one question remains- Why did Anakin cross over to the Dark Side? If the answer to this one question keeps an audience glued to the screen for over 2 hours (nearly 3 hours if you include the extra long break that Satyam took!), i would consider it no mean achievement.
ROTS, straddles the prequel world of movie making as well as the classical star wars world with reasonable ease (contemplated for 2 mins about using consumate here and then decided against it.. is that an attempt at being impartial or what?), be it in terms of the story line as well as in finer aspects like set design, costumes, dialogues etc where elements of the episodes 4,5 and 6 mix a little more happily with those from episodes 1 and 2.
-I like the fact that there are a few more 1 liners in this movie than in the previous 2. Obi-wan in particular.
- I liked the fact that some of the sets had clear references to the original series
- Vader looks immensely Vaderish (like Duh!, what i mean is that its good to see him on screen again, and i don't think he looks any less majestic this time than he did in the original)
-Liked the idea of giving Obi-wan the cool chameleon to ride on. (Don't ask why!)
Liked the idea that the circle is now complete!
May the foce be with you.